Monday, February 22, 2010

Envisioning Earthquakes, Violent Volcanoes and Subarctic Tsunamis

Explain
Cataclysmic events caused by earth's geological power are a fast-forward look at some of the forces behind the landscapes we see everyday. Earth's upheaval can quickly come to the forefront of our attention in the form of volcanoes, earthquakes and tsunamis. While some geological changes happen very slowly over time, devastating or violent natural phenomena can sometimes cause immediate changes to the landscape and to the lives of people in areas where these events occur. I think most people become interested in understanding the science behind such circumstances when an imminent, life-threatening, geologic event threatens to affect their lives. Hearing the stories of those who have experienced firsthand an earthquake, tsunami or volcanic eruption can stimulate a human connection through the shared experience of story telling, but can also spark an inquisitive interest in learning about what causes events like these to happen.

Extend

Looking up close in Google Earth at Lituya Bay of Alaska's Yukutat Peninsula, it is easy to see the light green ring of newer trees that have grown since the mega tsunami which occurred there in 1958. Natural events like these have been recorded both through oral histories of the people who live there as well as scientifically documented studies of the vegetation and area seismic activity.
Stories are an important part of most cultures. They explain the connections of the people to the land. One extension of this concept that came to mind was my experience spending a month in Costa Rica. A highlight of my time there was a horseback trip through the rainforest to the Arenal Volcano. Tourists visit this area because there are multiple mini-eruptions happening everyday. There are large booms and lava almost constantly spilling down the sides of the cone. The most spectacular time that I viewed the volcano was walking through the volcanic fields at the base of the volcano at night when it was bright red against the black sky.



The indigenous people of the area around the Arenal Volcano are the Maleku people. As a culture, living in the shadow of a volcano has influenced their daily lives and it is no surprise that the volcano is a force in their oral traditional stories. Out of all the different birds, monkeys, tree frogs, iguanas, and other types of wildlife I saw there, the most breathtaking was the blue morpho butterfly. I visited the Maleku Cultural Center and learned a story involving this butterfly and the volcano. It is said that a Maleku girl was saddened by losing a loved one in a tribal war. She was going to the top of the Arenal Volcano to ask for peace. On her way there, she fell in a river near a waterfall and drowned. As she went under the water, the volcano began to rumble, and out of the water came the first blue morpho butterfly.

Common Blue Morpho Butterfly  _ Morpho peleides

Evaluate
Science can influence indigenous cultures for better by adding more information and other perspectives to the already rich knowledge base of the people living in an area. On the other hand, if science disregards the native culture by not considering the viewpoint and values of a people, then both approaches fail to connect and learn from each other. Using the tradition of stories and experiences to learn from each other can help generate understanding as well as further interest in the underlying causes of events.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Formation of Landscapes, Formation of Cultures

















Explain
Out of the many places on Google Earth that I looked at, the two that I'm choosing to focus this post on are the place I am from, and a place in Alaska that I have not visited yet, but would really like to go someday. I will look at the landscapes of each and how they were formed, and also a little bit about the culture from each place. I lived in several mountain west states including Utah, Colorado and Wyoming. The above pictures are of Mill Hollow in Logan Canyon, and a Google Earth picture of the town where I grew up against the Bear River Mountain Range in Utah. Much of my time not spent in vocational or educational activities was spent with family in recreational activities, primarily outdoors. We had horses and I enjoyed horseback riding in the mountains, or with friends in the neighborhood. I went hiking a lot, both with family and friends, as well as skiing, canoeing and camping. These activities are a part of the culture I grew up in. They all rely on the local geological mountain formations which were formed through shifting along faults. The Cache Valley has been sinking for 12 million years, while the mountains have been being pushed upward from other forces.

















One place in Alaska that I would like to visit and learn more about is Unalaska. Last summer some of my husband's family friends, the Tellmans from Unalaska (top left in the photo), visited our home. They showed us pictures of the island and it was fascinating to hear more about a part of the state I've never been to from Native Alaskans. Unalaska is part of the Aleutian Islands and has a landscape which has been formed by volcanic action due to the Pacific plate subducting under Alaska. The volcano on that particular island is called Makushin Volcano and it is 5,691 feet tall. Steam is visible from the top of the volcano on clear days, though the Tellmans told me that there is a lot of fog on Unalaska.
Extend
I did not know a lot about the culture of the people of Unalaska, other than talking with the Tellmans a couple of times. My only other knowledge of this place came from reading a book, Aleutian Sparrow by Karen Hesse, which gave me some ideas about what it is like in that part of Alaska. The book is a work of historical fiction that takes place on or around Unalaska in the 1940's when the town is attacked by Japanese forces and the Native residents are held in camps in other locations in Southeast Alaska for the duration of the war. The book has some insights into the culture, the main thing relating to this post is that since the lives of the people were tied to the land of their island, the people had a very difficult time adjusting to another type of geographic location. They had provided for themselves and subsisted in their previous home. When the government moved them, it was thought that because it was the same state, it should be no problem for them to subsist as before. However, the landscape was completely different, and they didn't have the same ties to the different land and really struggled to survive in a new landscape.
The Qawalangin Tribe of the Unangan people makes up between 17%-30%(2000 US census) of the population of Unalaska. The island is very isolated and one way that the landscape shapes the culture is that being so far removed from other communities, the Native people have the knowledge of how to use the medicinal plants. Hear some other facts about the Native people of this area by listening to Laresa Syverson and Sharon Livingston, two members of the Qawalangin tribe.




Evaluate

The volcanic island of Unalaska has large altitude changes with different types of plants growing which are used both for food and for medicinal purposes. Also, the steep mountain slopes create a freshwater river where salmon spawn and are a food source for the people. If it weren't for plate techtonics, there would not be an island of Unalaska. Volcanic activity created it. Dutch Harbor has been among the largest fisheries in the country in terms of amount of seafood caught and brought to the port in Unalaska. Part of the culture there involves the value of caring for others in the community. The landscape, completely surrounded by water, seems to embody this cultural value by providing for the Native people for thousands of years. This value, reflected in the land itself, has shaped the culture and values of the Native people who live there.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

"The Cosmos is Within Us"

Explain
When Carl Sagan said that the cosmos is within us, it sums up some of the known ways that we are connected to our surroundings. All living creatures are connected to each other through biological processes and similarities. We are connected to the earth itself through our chemical makeup which is made from earth's elements. Modern physicists are also studying ways that the universe is connected to us atomically.
Among different populations, there are contrasting ways of understanding these connections. Here in Alaska, Native knowledge about our surroundings is centered around the types of knowledge needed to live in and have coexistence with the environment. The underlying purpose is not to set out to explain how nature works, but instead to gain an understanding of how to coexist with nature in an interconnected system. Knowledge is a whole body of information, rather than being split up into "science" and "spirituality". Native ways of knowing are connected to learning from the experiences of others, living close to nature and seeing the whole system and our part in that system as an everyday part of living. The learning of this type of knowledge is connected to both language and customs and people are dependent on their family, community and elders to teach them. This knowledge is used to help the family and community coexist and survive in their environment.
By contrast, Western science has a very different perspective on understanding the same systems. Western ways of knowing are much more involved with setting out to find an explanation for various components and phenomena. The "spiritual" or "supernatural" are not seen as forces in Western science. Through isolating and studying compartmentalized aspects in a more removed setting, research follows an analytical approach. Knowledge of this type may not come from being directly passed from individual to individual, but rather is "educated" through lectures and books. It is based on theories and laws which are often "proved" by recreatable results.
Extend
I watched a clip from a video titled, "The Birds of Winter" in which Nita Yurrliq Rearden from Shishmaref shares some advice given her by her Yupik grandmother upon her return from completing high school.
"You could adopt, adapt, use their strategies if it's worth doing. Know how to get along with them."
The advice concerned encouraging her to further her knowledge base in the Western ways of knowing, but it stood out to me that her advice should apply to anyone, that it should go both ways. Since cultures worldwide are intersecting more and more through technology, through population shifts and growth, knowing how to get along with and use other ways of knowing should be an advantage to Western science.
Evaluate
In subsistence lifestyles of Native Alaskans, getting food
involves knowledge of the winds, currents, tides, seasonal
changes and migrations as well as the social skills and
values involved like sharing, family and community.
Each is not a separate subject as they are all
interconnected in the way of living and being. An
advantage of understanding both Native and Western
ways of knowing is that Western science has the
technology to increase our vision beyond the earth and
see deeper into the universe. Understanding the Native
ways of knowing as well can help us see the universe as
a whole and consider the ways we may be connected on
an even larger scale. Maybe both ways of knowing
together can help to discover the ways, as Carl Sagan
said, "the cosmos is within us."